Common Chicago Author-Date citation mistakes
Chicago Author-Date errors often come from small formatting habits carried over from other styles. Use the checks below to review both your in-text citations and your reference list before you submit.
In-text citations and reference list entries do not match
Applies to: In-text citations & Reference list
In Chicago Author-Date, every in-text citation should point to a matching reference list entry, and every entry in the reference list should be cited in the text.
How to check: Read your reference list from top to bottom and confirm each entry is cited at least once in the text. Then scan your text for parenthetical citations and confirm each one has a matching entry in the reference list.
Adding a comma between the author and the year
Applies to: In-text citations
Chicago Author-Date does not use a comma between the author name and the year in a parenthetical citation. This is one of the most common habits people bring from other author-date styles.
How to check: Search your draft for citations that look like (Taylor, 2020). Remove the comma so the citation reads (Taylor 2020).
In-text citations are missing the year
Applies to: In-text citations
The year is part of the Chicago Author-Date system. If a citation includes an author name but no year, a reader cannot reliably match it to the correct entry in the reference list.
How to check: Scan every in-text citation and confirm it includes a year. For narrative citations, confirm the year appears in parentheses immediately after the author name.
Quoting specific passages without a page number or locator
Applies to: In-text citations
When you quote directly or point to a specific passage, Chicago Author-Date adds a page number or other locator to the citation so readers can find the exact place you used.
How to check: Review every quotation in your draft. If you see quotation marks but the nearby citation contains only an author and year, add a page number or locator where the source provides one.
Incorrect use of “et al.”
Applies to: In-text citations & Reference list
Chicago Author-Date shortens in-text citations for sources with three or more authors by using the first author’s last name followed by “et al.”.
In the reference list, the author list is handled differently. Sources with up to six authors list all authors. Sources with more than six authors list the first three followed by “et al.”.
How to check: For each multi-author source, confirm your in-text citations consistently use the same author form. Then confirm your reference list uses the appropriate author list length for that same source.
Using “&” instead of “and” in author names
Applies to: In-text citations & Reference list
Chicago style uses the word “and” between author names. Using an ampersand is a common carryover from other formats.
How to check: Search your document for “&”. If it appears between author names in citations or in the reference list, replace it with “and”.
Using the full title or a URL as an in-text citation
Applies to: In-text citations
Chicago Author-Date in-text citations are meant to be brief. They normally use an author name and year, not a URL or a full webpage title.
How to check: Search your draft for “http”, “https”, and “www”. If any appear inside parentheses as part of an in-text citation, remove them and use the author and year instead. If your source has no named author, use a shortened title that matches the beginning of the corresponding reference list entry, followed by the year.
Reference list entries are not in alphabetical order
Applies to: Reference list entries
Chicago Author-Date reference lists are arranged alphabetically so readers can locate entries quickly. A list that is out of order is harder to scan and easier to misread.
How to check: Confirm your reference list is sorted by author last name. For works with no named author, confirm you are sorting by the title used at the start of the entry.
Titles and source details are inconsistent across similar entries
Applies to: Reference list entries
Chicago Author-Date relies on a consistent order of elements. When similar sources are formatted in noticeably different ways, readers may struggle to compare them or identify what is missing.
How to check: Group your entries by source type, such as books, journal articles, and websites. Compare two or three entries in the same group and confirm they follow the same element order and include the same kinds of publication details.
Tip: If a citation looks unusual, verify the source details first. Most Chicago Author-Date problems come from missing metadata rather than the punctuation.